Survey undertaken via This Is Not A Gateway mailing list.

Survey closed Feb 13th 2013.



Still very much needed as there are almost no forums to discuss alternative urbanisms

It is a very important event, it tackles on many cases that should be discussed by the public.


I think that is really important …bringing people together who otherwise might not.


Yes very important. There are very few opportunities for those not in academia to access this kind of event and share thinking, knowledge and strategies in this way. I value what TINAG does very highly - especially the democratic/open ideals behind it.


It is an event of many different disciplines and independent off any corporations. I will do my best to contribute in the future for it to continue.


Super important -- really great and unique!


I think the festival is important, there really is not anything like it.


Would like it to have more exhibition / performance based work (has good to see Mark McG's Taxi videos all in one place, though did not have time to sit down there). So I do hope you go from strength to strength and keep it as free as you possibly can. Many thanks

I loved it!


Yes , it important , everyone should be aware what is going on in the world and why.


I think though small, the Festival is an intellectually and politically honest way of addressing a lot of issues which either only get talked about at academic conferences or in 'activist' or grassroots settings. Viva TINAG!


It is needed more than ever. I can't wait for the next one!


The festival is VITAL and UNIQUE. It open perspectives, widen our horizons and make people think and look differently at the world they live in. It reveals how everything is interconnected and how we can act daily by thinking responsibly.


Just an ace event. More speakers next time!


It's a great idea in a great space.


Yes, the festival is important, it is also important to be free. Some other form of subsidy has to be invented than entrance fees.


I think the festival is a great contribution to a much needed critical discussion about how cities are planned / built / governed / changed and how community groups and individuals can make a difference.


It's an interesting concept that provides a different atmosphere to many "activist" meetings. i'd def return another year.


I think TINAG is a necessary component of our cultural need today, to inspire contemporary thinking on the city, and provide a space for dynamic ideas be shared amongst fellow people with an interest in their cities.


It's pretty unique in London as an event looking critically in a cross-disciplinary way at issues about economic and global issues.  Also the wide range of interaction (talks, films, workshops) and the fact that it's been free makes it very accessible.


the festival is definitely needed and important, because of the relevant social issues it addressed and because it was accessible for everyone.


The TINAG festival is definitely needed. It's critical voice and open approach is rare today.


It's DEFINATELY NEEDED. and DEFINATELY IMPORTANT. There is nothing similar out there that I know of. I found the whole thing intellectually stimulating. It hasn't happened for a long time. It made me think about what I could do to make my actions more effective.

There should be more TINAG everywhere. More festivals like TINAG, more days of TINAG, more spaces like TINAG.


It is very important to keep a critical spirit alive and it serves as a base for discussion as the book shows. Looking forward to next year!


great program, beautiful and productive space!


Great programme, very interesting selection people and issues.


The atmoshpere and the approach are really informal and friendly, but at the same time you can find people seriously engaged and passionate. This aspect lead to very critical discourse.


A wide variety of events. Very well organised, in a quiet, understated, yet professional way. I felt very included. The atmosphere was respectful towards different views etc.. The exhibitions were interesting and varied.


Loved it - very good atmosphere, friendly and approachable, excellent venue. Always something on to see/listen to.




Loved it.


I absolutely loved the festival.  The atmosphere was great, although I had a hankering to make it more festival like, perhaps with the addition of some poetry, comedy and/or music, maybe an evening gig or open mic session.  I found the programme full and varied, but would have liked some scheduled breaks to chat more and meet people.


The participants that I met all seemed great and I was pleased to meet people who had been opposing the Olympics and people from the occupy movement etc.  I was also particularly moved by the talk about the Idle No More campaign and meeting Sylvia from Turtle Island. The exhibitions were great too.  I really enjoyed watching some of the Taxi Driver’s films though.  I was very inspired by the whole festival and although hard up stumped up the cash to buy a book.


It was very well organised, very welcome and a good atmosphere.


Very good atmosphere, amazing diversity of issues discussed


I thought the Bishopsgate Inst was an excellent venue in many ways - calm, spacious, good facilities- and it was good having a cafe/ exhib space/bookshop for people to get together and chat!


Amazing venue! It's nice to have an inclusive festival, not dry and regulated, but sometimes felt a bit 'off-topic'!


Absolutely brilliant! Just so upset that I missed the Saturday. Wish I'd heard about it before the Saturday evening - perhaps you could have teamed up with different organisations to get the word out about it.


Brilliant. Intimate talks in rooms which felt like living rooms - perfect environment for critical debate!


Really positive, constructive and collaborative.


Was diverse in content and presentation, with interesting debates. Am looking forward to seeing some of the contributions in Critical Cities Vol 4.  It may be an idea to make some of the presentations available on the Tinag website for those who could not attend and give them an opportunity to respond.


I think it is great forum for sharing ideas about cities/communities, the location was very good as it had different spaces with different content and a real festival spirit amongst the bookshelves in the archive, corridors with displays and rooms where discussions took place. All round an amazing experience. The only downside was that it was impossible to hear all the interesting talks as they where happening simultaneously but such is the nature of festivals.


I think TINAG is a fantastic space for the bringing together of minds on the subjects that matter today in the contemporary city.  The atmosphere was relaxed and inviting and the Bishopsgate Institute was a great host.  The programme was diverse, and I especially liked the inclusion of artists work alongside the film and more 'formal' discussion/talks.


Overall, a fantastic and unique event to have been part of.

Good atmosphere, great programme.  The Bishopsgate venue was very confortable.  Was good to have a cafe/break out space.


Excellent programme


Atmosphere was nice and relaxed, approach was good and critical. Great talks, wide range of speakers. Cafe was really nice as well.


Loved it all!


Great atmosphere, interesting programme, good exhibitions, nice café.


I thought it was amazing. I liked everything I attended. There participants were excellent, good speakers and who inspired action. The food was good but a bit bready. I did not dislike anything I saw or heard or the organisation of it. I think was there was almost too much going on for a single day. Maybe less is more.


Great - venue excellent, bookshop had some good offers, exhibitions good, participants like Sylvia Mcadam, Gary Mcgrew and Hamja Ahsan were amazing


It was fantastic. The programme was very rich, touching upon many different interesting subjects. The space for exchange was an essential part of it. Truly wonderful.


I received many really nice comment on several conferences of people that came to see me and attend to some of them. For me was a really nice experience, as space in time to talk freely about thinks that matters.


The festival served as a very good meeting point for critical people to numerous topics. The Bishopsgate Institute was just a wonderful location to host the different events. It was a very exciting experience for me!


A precious thing - distilling anger into action. I parted with renewed hope.


Talks and conferences were really amazing. I liked them because the festival is extremely local, but at the same time global. Specific themes can be understood by everybody.


It was great to meet like minded people at such a creative event. I liked the dynamic feel the festival had. It didn't feel as if you were a passive participant.


Great speakers, really interesting topics, really important/unique philosophy and viewpoint of the festival.


I wanted to participate because I had enjoyed the events I went to in 2010 festival - I agree with your ethos thought the people turning up were prepared not just to listen but to speak and critically evaluate. I like the 'it's what you make it' ethos so I wanted to be part of it and I'm really really glad I did!


Everything really and because you are simply exceptional. The philosophy of the organisation and the critical programme plus speakers.


The programme as a whole and an interest in critical thinking and perspectives on urban development.


List of speakers and the generosity of this being a free festival with a wide range of critically sharp debates about the urban environment and cultural, social, and political contexts.





Survey undertaken via This Is Not A Gateway mailing list.

Survey closed November 2010  


98.9 % - Plan to attend the next festival

93.3% - Have recommended the festival to other people


. . . . . . . . . . .


The main impacts of 2010 Festival, listed in order by Festival Participants are:



New learning & New knowledge

New approach to addressing urban questions

New contacts



Festival Participants listed in order, the most valuable aspects of the festival as:


Critical approach

Cross-disciplinary methods

Free and open to all

Exists somewhere between 'the academy and the street'

Scale and breath of the programme

Focus on participants outside of 'establishment urban curcuits'



Listed, in order, are the main reasons why participants decided to attend the Festival:


The underlining philosophy of This Is Not A Gateway

The chance to be critical and discursive

The diverse programme

The opportunity to meet other critical thinkers


Festival Participants listed, in order, the most interesting activities from the festival programme as:










. . . . . . . . . . .


Additional comments include: 


The whole festival was thoroughly thought provoking


The ideological approach across all the mediums is a very honest and rare quality


The selection is spot on, timetable very rich and the quality is everywhere


The festival was really interesting; very good art there, difficult to see in the crush


I do think TINAG is pretty unique ... a packed programme of such quality and cross-disciplinary contributors.


The festival is now one of the most important events on the cultural calendar


TINAG festival provided a much- needed platform for critical thinking and action within the professions/disciplines of the built environment.


TINAG and the festival are vital


4 of 5 stars


Brief but so intense


I feel uplifted from the weekend


Amazingly well organized, full of interesting people … an important rigorous discursive event!


I came away simultaneously exhausted and over-stimulated from all the ideas and interesting people


Enjoyed it, large audience; interesting bunch. Still thinking about talks and people.


Excellent and Challenging


Excellent, interesting, diverse, interesting programme. Very thoughtfully curated.


Fantastic, really packed with people who wanted to share ideas and listen.


I found it thought-provoking and inspiring


Rich, open minded, multi-disciplinary, efficient, focused, intelligent, honest, unique


8 out of ten


Very constructive; a pleasure, the new kind of organisation we need


Very interesting, varied and stimulating event


Very well organised and interesting programme.


Successful … welcoming, friendly and inclusive but still critically rigorous.


Enjoyed it very much. Challenging yet comfortable. Very well put together.


Very fulfilling and inspiring. All the sessions that I attended were brilliant.


This is an amazing platform for independent discussion.


Fantastic, really packed with people who wanted to share ideas and listen




Each year gets better than the last


Great initiative. The programme was amazing! Seemed very well organised!


It was very stimulating, attended by knowledgeable and engaged people from all walks of life and most of them with a personal commitment to develop alternative approaches.


Great to see such a broad spectrum of ideas and perspectives of the city from a variety of sectors and backgrounds.


Was refreshing to be amongst so many unpretentious people willing to be open to new thoughts and learn!


The place in London where the chances are high to meet people that can push one’s ideas and understandings further.


A very interesting alternative to existing dictated cultural forms.


You could see people reflecting on their own thoughts, approaches and experiences. People in and out of the sessions seemed eager to share and listen.


Everything I saw was great, from the opening evening to the final session I attended.


The welcoming and relaxed atmosphere was wonderful.


The atmosphere was great, I hope the festival continues for many years to come!


Thoroughly enjoyed it,and great atmosphere of friendliness and enthusiasm.


Opening launch was fantastic. Venue was terrific. Speakers were good!


Each of the discussions, exhibitions and presentations I attended was interesting,  engaging and thought provoking in a different way. It was a great space to meet and listen to interesting people from all over the world.


It was intellectually stimulating and thoughtfully organised, bought together a range of people in an open, democratic and unpretentious space; an environment of sincerity.






The informal and friendly nature, the passionate and critical discussions across disciplines, cultures and everyday experiences are invaluable.




I found the diversity of people attending particularly great. The mix of people from different ages and with different professional backgrounds was great.




On the whole, I just loved it!




I thought it was a really nice atmosphere, and everyone who was attending was totally interested in the programme.




There is no other event of this kind, anywhere!